Click to get your own widget

Thursday, June 19, 2014

Going Beyond Maurice Saatchi's Cutting Corporation Tax Idea

    Maurice Saatchi has produced for the Centre For Policy Studies (and implicitly for the Tory Party) a proposal to abolish Corporation Tax for all but the 10% of largest companies and also abolish Capital Gains Tax for the same people. Saying

"The Policy outlined in this document will:
 abolish Corporation Tax for 90% of UK companies
 reduce the deficit faster than predicted by the OBR 
 expand employment faster than predicted by the OBR
 increase competition and challenge Cartel Capitalism
 let millions of people grow tall. 
These millions of individuals will enjoy:
 the opportunity to say “I am the captain of my ship”
 more money
 more freedom
 the first step on The Road from Serfdom.
The nation as a whole will benefit from:
 a change in culture as big as “Own your own Home” in the 1980s
 greater economic growth and lower unemployment than forecast by the OBR
 more competitive market places
 more freedom and independence from Big Government and Big Companies."
 

   I have been pushing for CT cuts since before I started this blog in 2004. Basically following the example of Ireland where they cut CT, in a series of steps to 12.5%, and reduced regulation, particularly on housebuilding and achieved a 7% average growth rate.

    So what do I think of Saatchi's slightly different proposal? It is an improvement. His is costed at £10.5 bn. Mine of cutting all CT by slightly more than half would cost just over a billion more. Not much difference. However by concentrating it all on smaller companies he gets some advantages - smaller companies provide more employment growth; smaller companies tend to be more innovative, until they grow into bigger companies; smaller companies have more difficulty borrowing so profits are more important for expansion.

    He also has the advantage of being able to run it through an economic model. Lets take advantage of that.

    The conclusion is that this £10.5 bn cut would increase growth by about 0.8%, though not in the first year because the investment has to work through. That means that by the end of a 5 year Parliament that growth would have replaced all that tax cut. Saatchi says that this 0.8% estimate is "conservative" and I agree. Indeed that is 1 of 3 reasons I believe the position is much better than he offers:

1 - Irish growth was 7% - 4.5% better than ours. Even if we assume more than half was due  to the regulatory cuts (not the common feeling but probably true) and that, because Ireland is so much smaller than us, having lower taxes opened them up to proportionately more investment than us we still come out with the growth potential being around twice the 0.8% given. Also Irish growth did not take a year to take off and this is reasonable if investors see an improved investment opportunity - they will not wait, but start investing immediately, if they can.

2 - Increased national debt is only a problem in relation to the size of the economy. If we have growth of an extra 0.8% in the economy, debt can increase the same without making payment more difficult. Indeed if the size of government is unaltered there is actually proportionately more uncommitted money in the economy, though this is only a marginal effect.

Our current national debt is £1.4 trillion so 0.8% is £11.2 bn, just slightly above initial and maximum borrowing.

3 - If you have a growing economy you need to increase the money supply to keep prices stable. Money in UK circulation is rather larger than 1 year's gdp. In fact it was £2,200 bn in 2010 - presumably about £2,400 bn now. So an extra unexpected 0.8% growth means we can and should print £19 billion extra.
--------------------
   This is not estimating conservatively but it is the realistic best estimate and if we don't do it there is no reason to believe reality will be conservative either.

    So clearly we should go with this asap.

   I would go further - promise that the take on CT and other business taxes will not be allowed to rise - if the economy grows, as it will, increasing the tax take, we will raise the level at which CT comes in (and when it is fully abolished, business rated and other such taxes). This means investors can look forward to a stable profitable investment, which is all they need.
--------------------

    But I would like to see this as merely the start.

    The formula for economic growth is:     Economic Freedom + Cheap Energy

    Low business tax is only part, the smaller part, of economic freedom. The greater part is not having parasitic state regulation. At least tax money goes back into the economy, albeit in less efficient ways and excluding the cost of government taxing and returning it. Wealth destroyed by regulation, for example 98% of the cost of electricity, is gone forever.

   So we should should cut regulations wherever possible. As a minor effect that also cuts government spending a bit - it costs government all of 1/20th, to regulate, of what it costs the productive economy to be regulated.

75% of housing cost is regulatory - 34% X 75% = 25.5%
(I assume this includes heating it)

The EU regulations come to another 5%
(assuming the cost is equally borne by the people as by the government sector which is an optimistic assumption)

Remaining portion of income that goes to the value of what we actually choose
100% - 25.5% - 5% =69.5%

That 69.5% is, in turn reduced proportionately by all the other factors. Take off commercial building costs (est 2.5%), electricity charges through the rest of the economy (est 2%),accountancy (7.5%), child care (est 2.5%), assorted other (est 10%)
Total 24.5%

Therefore percentage of income we nominally get to spend which we actually get in our pockets & spent on the product not the surrounding regulation
69.5% X (100% - 24.5% = 52.5%
  
     But if the regulatory part of economic freedom costs us more than the tax part the other side of the equation, cheap energy has even more potential. Roger Helmer has written of the advantages of letting decisions on electricity be made on economic not ideological grounds.

    The correlation between growth in energy use and in gdp is undisputable.

Enerconics1_html_m68263661
        It has been calculated and indeed is undisputed that app 98% of the cost of producing electricity here is governmental parasitism. 

       Nuclear is currently 40% of the average cost of our power basket.
China is building at 0.27 our costs.

Because China is building in three years and us in ten we have seven years foregone income while paying interest – assuming the normal 10% return that is 1.10^7 = 1.95
Assume China is not entirely without state parasitism – say 10% 
VAT and carbon levies 20%
How much could cost be reduced if it was allowed to mass produce reactors - three fold seems a conservative estimate.

60% X 0.27 X 1/1.95 X 90% X 1/1.20% X 1/3 = 0.0208 or 2.08% of current costs.
97.92% parasitism.
       Major reductions, not quite as major, could be done by allowing the market to produce shale gas. Any reduction on electricity costs, not just one as major as this, if the laws of supply and  demand work, would produce a many fold increase in energy use and therefore a many fold increase in gdp.

       Indeed I have previously proposed a 24 point programme to the world's fastest growth, which includes my original CT cutting proposal, and it would work. Theoretically we might expect most of the proposals to increase growth by about an average of 2% a year, Some more, some less.

       In practice we might be limited to a bit above the 20% growth Guandong province in China managed for years. Certainly the theoretical maximum, if we make growth our "Number one priority" (Scottish labour leader Jack McConnell promising at 2 elections - he knew what people want even if he lied about giving it) cannot be lower than the actually achieved maximum.

=================================
      Saatchi's proposal is a very good one, well thought out and verified. It is a small fraction of our potential.

       

Labels: , , ,


Comments:
Thanks for sharing this best stuff with us! Keep sharing! I am new in the blog writing.All types blogs and posts are not helpful for the readers.Here the author is giving good thoughts and suggestions to each and every readers through this article.Quality of the content is the main element of the
blog and this is the way of writing and presenting.Waiting for again wonderful blogs or posts.
custom essay writing service

 
You need to kill time, you need entertainment. Refer to our website. hope you get the most comfort.
Thanks for sharing !
Friv 5
Kizi 1
Yepi 3
 
I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people.
- five nights at freddy's
- five nights at candy's

 
Asia mixed in subdued trade; Tokyo closed for public holiday.
Europe mixed as oil rebounds; FTSE 100 up, sterling firm ahead of BoE.
U.S. stock index futures lower.
 
Pretty good post! I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that grademiners.com review
I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.
 
It can be out and out humiliating to ask from companions or family and if Mastercards are pushed to the limit there is by all accounts no chance to get out.
 
Once these pre requirements are done, the borrower can immediately apply for the credit through the online administrations, which thus will quicken the whole speed of the endorsement and preparing.
 
On the off chance that you neglect to reimburse a payday credit then the punishments can be serious.
 
Auto title credits offer an awesome answer for those requiring additional cash amid assess time, either to pay Uncle Sam or to cover different costs amid the more slender days charge time can cause.
 
You essentially need to persuade the bank with a substantial reason and need to pay an extra sum other than the premium.
 
تعتبر شركة الحورس من أحسن الشركات بالمملكة العربية السعودية فى مجال التنظيف و أفضلهم على الاطلاق فنحن نسعى دوما للحفاظ على صدارة شركات النظافة و ذلك بتطوير الأفراد و المعدات و المواد المستخدمة لضمان تقديم أفضل خدمة ممكنة لعملائنا الكرام كما نوضح لك مدى جمال و نظافة المظهر الطبيعي للمكان و من حيث ياتيك اطمئنان ليتم التاكيد من مصداقية الخدمات المقدمة فتعامل معنا لكى تحصل على افضل الخدمات لاتمام عملية النظافة و بأسعار مناسبة للجميع كما نقدم العديد من خدمات التنظيف للبيوت والفلل والقصور والشقق فنحن نقدم أرخص خدمات التنظيف كما نضمن لك الراحة و الامان فى بيتك فنحن نقوم بازالة الروائح من المنزل و اضافة رائحة منعشة و متجددة للمكان باستخدام افضل المعطرات و المطهرات كما نعمل على تنظيف و تطهير الحمامات و المطابخ كما نعمل على تنظيف و ازالة الغبار من داخل المنزل و خارجه كما نقوم بجلى البلاط و تلميعه و تنظيف النوافذ و الابواب و غسل الستائر و تنظيف الواجهات الزجاجية والحجرية و تلميع الارضيات و نظافة الموكيت و السجاد مع التعطير و كل ما يلزم لتنظيف و تطهير المنزل كما نقوم بتنظيف المجالس بكل انواعها من الارضية و العلوية حيث أن مجالسنا هى المكان المفضل دائما فى المنزل
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالباحه
شركة نقل اثاث وعفش بالباحه
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالباحه
شركة تنظيف بالباحه
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالباحه
شركة رش مبيدات بالباحه
 

شركتنا شركة الشرق الاوسط شركة نقل اثاث بابها وهي مميزة دائما عن غيرها وذلك لأنها تمتلك أفضل فريق عمل مدرب ومضمون ومتدرب علي اعلي مستوي وغير ذلك فشركتنا تتميز أيضا بأنها تعمل علي استخدام أفضل المعدات واحدث الأدوات وأيضا تتميز شركتنا بالحرص علي استخدام أجود المواد في مواد التي تستخدم في التغليف من الورق و الكرتون والبلاستيك والقماش وأيا الإسفنج وذلك مما يضمن عدم تجريح شركة نقل اثاث بحائل أي كم قطع الأثاث وذلك مهما كان نوعها ومهما كانت حساسيتها أيضا وأيضا مهما طالت مسافة نقلها وذلك ما يميز شركة نقل عفش بحائل وأيضا شركتنا تتميز أيضا بأنها تمتلك أفضل وسائل النقل المميزة وذلك بتميز الشركة بأنها تمتلك احدث أنواع سيارات نقل الأثاث التي تكون مجهزة لهذا الغرض والتي أيضا تضمن لكم النقل والوصول للمكان في أسرع وقت ولان شركتنا تعلم جيدا قيمة الأثاث وانه لا غني عنه بشكل كبير في كافة البيوت لذلك نهتم جيدا بالمحافظة عليه كما أن شركتنا شركة نقل اثاث بنجران تتميز أيضا بان هي من الشركات المميزة التي تهتم برأي العملاء دائما وتعمل دائما في السعي علي إرضاء جميع عملائها فجميعنا نعلم أن هذا التميز يكون ليس موجود في باقي الشركات ويعتبر من أهم ما يميز الشركة فالعمل علي الاهتمام دائما برئي العملاء هو يعتبر بناء أساسي في نجاح أي شركة وأيضا شركتنا شركة نقل شركة الشرق الاوسط شركة تنظيف بخميس مشيط تتميز بأنها تعمل دائما بالتواصل السريع وأيضا تقوم بتقديم خدمات جميع عملائها بالسرعة وبالرغم من السرعة ألي أن الشركة تهتم بجميع التفاصيل وبدقة عالية وبتقديم جميع الخدمات بأسرع وقت وبخدماته كاملا وهذا ما يميز شركتنا عن غيرها فشركة نقل الأثاث تتميز عن الكثير من الشركات ومما وضحنا إليكم بعض مميزاتها فشركتنا شركة تنظيف بمحايل عسير تقدم لكم الخدمات المتعددة وذلك في عملية نقل الأثاث أو العفش فشركتنا تعتبر من رواد في نقل العفش فالشركة تقدم خدمة خدمة التنظيف شركة تنظيف ببيشة لجميع عملائها خدمات علي اعلي مستوي من الجودة العالية وذلك من خلال استخدام أجود وأفضل الأدوات والتي أيضا تعمل شركة نقل الأثاث علي تقديم جميع الخدمات الكاملة والمميزة والتي تكون ذات الكفاءة العالية كل هذا معنا فى شركة تنظيف منازل بنجران التى تعتبر من اهم مايميزنا فى منطثة نجران بشهاده عملائنا

 
Not all are true. Everyone has their own way of thinking but I think they have to reconsider. I like to argue for the most accurate results.
fivenightsatfreddysplay.com

 

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم عميلنا العزيز نحن نقدم افضل خدمات تنظيف المجالس والشقق بافضل انواع

التنظيفات المشهود لها عالميا
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالطائف
شركة تنظيف مجالس بجازان
شركة تنظيف مجالس بحائل
ونحن فى خماتكم 24 ساعة على مدار الشهر



 
Do not suffer after the day with our company, the Knights of Dammam, where our company provides the best home services at all and we have a section of cleaning and control and sewerage and insulation, as well as we have a special section of anti-termites and we have a special cleaning of reservoirs, and our shop cleaning boards and the best cleaning and cleaning materials Modern machines.
Home cleaning company in Dammam


Transport company in Dammam


House cleaning company Babha

Taslik sewer company in Dammam

Roof Insulation Company in Dammam

An insect control company in Dammam


Company for the control of white ants in Dammam


Company cleaning boards and Knab Dammam



 
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

British Blogs.